Visions for America in this Election Year
With both domestic and international consequences in mind, we have asked our readers to express their visions for the future of the United States—recognizing that U.S. domestic politics reverberate far beyond U.S. geographical borders. In response, we have received expressions ranging from hopeful and generous to fearful and condemnatory—reflecting the powerful emotions generating, and generated by, current U.S. and global affairs.
Persimmon Tree welcomes additional comments on this important topic—observations from those of all political persuasions, for a forum is a place for exchanging different views and learning from one other.
Concern for the future will undoubtedly be reflected in future Persimmon Tree Forums as this year unfolds. In the meantime, we welcome your responses via the Comment section at the end of this page.
On February 8, some eight thousand writers – poets, fiction and nonfiction writers, and those who refuse to be categorized – came to my city for the annual AWP conference. Hundreds of publishers covered one entire floor of the convention center, while hundreds of workshops occupied other floors. Jericho Brown delivered a stunning keynote address.
In other words, my Midwestern city was invaded–in the best sense of the word–by the latest and greatest, as well as those seeking their wisdom.
These were my people – writers. But it felt like another country, one in which there was true diversity, equality, and inclusivity (DEI). Walking those wide halls were people of every color and gender who felt free to express themselves on paper and in life.
Traditional bathroom signs were covered with ones that said “all genders.” Workshop announcements pointed out accommodations for disabilities, visible or invisible.
My vision for this country’s future is to create the feeling the AWP created–a feeling of freedom, equality, optimism, inclusivity, and respect. I understand that we’ll have to work hard to make this feeling a reality for all of society. Indeed, that is the challenge that I, as an American, look forward to.
Maril Crabtree
Mission, Kansas
We must urge voters to turn out to defeat an ignoble candidate.
Hope Prosky
Brooklyn, New York
Rita Ariyoshi
Honolulu, Hawaii
Elaine – Peace for All, part of the portrait series, Women Who Refuse to be Invisible
(a series that focuses on women over 60), mixed media, by Anastasia Andersen
I am disappointed in our country’s leadership, the dearth of objective discourse, the shirking of responsibility, the irrational actions that prevent progress on the serious and significant issues facing the world today.
Yet, I dream of a future for our children and grandchildren that is safe, healthy, and compassionate. I do not know how we get from where we are today to a place where we have re-established trust in our leaders and institutions, where differences are celebrated and tolerated, not berated and silenced, and where equity is natural, not forced. I will try, though, to be part of the solution, for the goodness of us all.
Patricia Burgess
Chapel Hill, North Carolina
The opposite is to continue on the current path to more division, more war, more pain, and more destruction. What will the United States and the world be like in a year, five years, or ten years if we continue on this path?
For the sake of all that is living, individuals must make the choice to embrace and build rather than to harm and destroy.
Dr. Elizabeth Barbara Brown
Rockford, Illinois
(Letter to presidential candidates)
As we move beyond the debates and competition for the 2024 presidential nominations, I hope you will move beyond the rhetoric and begin to focus on the critical challenges. We are all too familiar with the current disconnect, disillusion, duplicity, indifference and confusion. I hope we can move beyond the promises, slogans, innuendos, and tired clichés. The domestic and international agendas for our country demand special insight and skills of leadership unparalleled in our history. Too many Americans are disillusioned, pessimistic, and devoid of hope. Unfair competition, dishonesty, and greed in the corporate world have left us morally bankrupt. We are in a crisis, struggling to live our creed. We are pushing human boundaries, caught up in things which prevent us from seeing the best in each other. Our historical documents are not perfect or absolute, but my hope is that we have the capacity to make them more perfect and live out the promise of our experiment in democracy. Our political leaders, once elected, have frequently ignored the mandates and expectations of those they represent.
My hope is if you are elected, you will not become just another resident in the White House. I need to know that my vote will not just maintain the status quo. I hope you will select a bipartisan coalition of talented Americans to work with you on critical issues, to restore the dignity and respect of our great country in the community of nations, to move us beyond mediocrity and complacency, to liberate us from the poverty of ignorance, the bondage of class status, the myopia of ethnocentrism, and the curse of cultural conceit. We need leadership that understands “that values travel at the speed of fax and cultures cross at the speed of light.”
I have to believe that if elected, you will move beyond the rhetoric and make the terms statesman and politician mutually exclusive. I have to believe that if elected, you will have the confidence, compassion, courage, and vision to restore our dignity, quality of life, and belief in the American dream.
CONVINCE ME THAT I AM RIGHT!
Barbara Johnson
Las Vegas, Nevada
Don’t trust anyone. They’re after us.
I heard these warnings all my life.
This is the fabric of my Russian Jewish heritage.
The pogroms slaughtered my grandparents’ village in Odessa.
They were lucky to have emigrated to America.
I watched White Supremacists and Nationalists chant, “Jews Will Not Replace Us” at their 2017 Unite the Right Rally in Charlottesville, Virginia.
Fear prickled every muscle, nerve, and bone in my body.
Sleepless nights were filled with images of the Holocaust death camp prisoners.
Former President Trump embraced the Proud Boys and the Boogaloo Movement.
He did not denounce the Unite the Right and blamed the homegrown terrorists, who murdered Jews and Christians where they worshipped, on mental illness.
After Biden defeated Trump in 2020, the GOP and their voters supported the former president’s “Stop the Steal Campaign” and dismissed the January 6, 2021, storming of the Capitol in Washington, D.C. as tourism.
During the Biden administration, the former president was indicted on 91 felony counts including pressuring Georgia Secretary of State Raffensperger “to find 11,000 votes” to win Georgia.
Trump praises Russian President Putin, a dictator who eliminates his adversaries.
My fears have escalated to horror if Biden does not win in 2024.
Marilyn June Janson
Mesa, Arizona
Vicki, part of the portrait series, Women Who Refuse to be Invisible
(a series that focuses on women over 60), mixed media, by Anastasia Andersen
I’m thinking of my students this election year, the ones I taught in college freshman English years ago. Wondering if they remember what I told them—and if they’re the voices of reason in the room, their board rooms, church basements, grocery stores, homes . . .
The ones who think. Who question and weigh. Who know how words work and how they can be used. To tell the truth or lie. To persuade or manipulate. The power they have over our lives. How easy it is to be fooled, taken advantage of.
I told them that knowing how to think was their best defense, and knowing how to read and write their greatest powers. That if they didn’t know, they were giving their power away or letting someone else take it. Never clearer than this year.
What I wish for us all, for our country, is that we not give our power away. That we cherish it and guard it and use it wisely.
I wonder, with the things happening today, if some of them are having quiet aha! moments, if they haven’t already [had them], thinking to themselves, “Oh! That’s just what my English teacher said.”
Rosetta Radtke
Savannah, Georgia
I feel compelled to write because we have a son and his young family living and working in Pennsylvania and my husband and I are terrified for them.
Your excessive gun violence and bizarre politics worry us to no end. Your big, beautiful country on our southern border barely survived the insanity of Donald Trump’s last presidency, and yet here you are preparing very possibly to embark on another four years of chaos and undemocratic governance. Why and how is this even possible?
Canadians are confused. We witnessed this man refuse to concede to Joe Biden and then purposefully incite a scary insurrection where people died. We’ve heard New York find him and his sons guilty of fraud in how they run their business in that state. There are more indictments than is conceivable pending or appealed or blah, blah, blah surrounding this man, and yet he has the kind of hold on your Congress that makes them not pass a bill that Ukraine desperately needs to happen. Again, to be clear, he holds no office right now and is still the puppet master. Are there no Republicans with the brains and backbone to oppose him? Can you not imagine the pumped, vengeful, erratic president/dictator he will be if elected next November? Horrifying for the U.S.A. and for the world!
But most unforgivable of all, Trump is in that murdering monster Putin’s pocket. He’ll help Putin destroy Ukraine and then move on to Poland and other NATO countries, triggering WWIII. That MAGA red hat he and his delusional far right base wear is a symbol for “Autocracy in America,” and they’re all blind to it. Trump and Putin exist for power and their sick narcissism feeds their addiction every day.
Sylvia Fiorelli
Brampton, Ontario, Canada
The Four Horsemen of the (Possible) Apocalypse, cartoon drawing by Ciel Downing
Mary Hiland
Gahanna, Ohio
I am taking a walk in the evening. I am enjoying the ocean breeze on the Malecón in Havana, Cuba, the yellow marigolds and colorful Catrina statues lining the streets for Día de los Muertos in Oaxaca, Mexico. Neither of these cities is in a country known for its safety, but I am breathing freely, not looking nervously over my shoulder when I hear footsteps behind me. That is because in neither place is it legal for people to be armed to the teeth.
How much of the joy and excitement of cities has been lost in the United States because of our national obsession with guns. The rest of the world thinks that we have lost our minds, and rightfully so. Parents in other countries are reluctant to send their children to the U.S. to study because they believe it is not safe. Large public celebrations have become terrifying because a mentally ill person or a person with a grudge may at any moment start shooting.
I want the freedom to enjoy the cities of my country. I will vote only for candidates who believe that safety from gun violence is a critical priority.
Susan K. Glassman
St. Louis, Missouri
If I could choose a future for this country, it would be one where the permanent political class in Washington, D.C., was out of business. Lobbyists would not be allowed to contribute to political campaigns. It would be against the law for any politician or political action committee to take money from lobbyists.
I would also like to see term limits set on senators and representatives. Each senator could serve for two terms (twelve years), and each representative could serve for six terms (twelve years). That way politicians could get down to the business of solving the problems in our country instead of voting in order to become a permanent fixture in Washington.
I would also like to see age limits set on our presidential candidates. No candidate could run for the office of president over the age of seventy-two. That way we would not be dealing with the problem of mental competency with the holders of our highest office.
I would like the political culture to change so that each party would work with the opposing party to get constructive legislation passed and not view “compromise” as a dirty word.
Valerie Cullers
Meridian, Idaho
Scream after Reading the Morning Headlines (Self Portrait), part of the portrait series, Women Who Refuse to be Invisible
(a series that focuses on women over 60), mixed media, by Anastasia Andersen
Israel is flattening Gaza and eliminating its residents, dropping mega-bombs the U.S. has given them, along with their annual $3.85 billion in aid. Civilian casualties in Gaza topped those in Ukraine in less than two months.
At home as many as six million people are without shelter (the official figure is 500,000 some homeless, but experts believe it to be much higher). A far greater number face hunger and lack of medical care. Let’s tell our representatives and presidential candidates that we want our tax dollars spent on welfare, not warfare, in 2024 and thereafter. The world would be a better place.
Sally Abbott
San Francisco, California
Suzanne S. Austin-Hill
Ruskin, Florida
In this election, separating the candidates from the issues is like separating paint from a wall. No single issue worries me more than others, for all of them could be part of the same horrific picture. Zero gun laws, reactionary election laws, the repeal of Roe: all will dominate the political landscape if one candidate in particular wins.
As I write this, a knot tightens in my stomach; I gulp down nausea. The only relief is thinking that life under these circumstances would be short-lived for me and my fellow elders. I have the utmost sympathy for Americans who are young, as they will live with laws that were heretofore unimaginable.
Those of us in our final decades have taken for granted the democracy and good will we’ve always known. Even folks who for centuries have been the victims of racism and oppression have a fondness for the freedoms they have had. Under a possible dictatorship, oppression will be more evenly distributed and institutionalized. Only a relatively small group of devoted loyalists will be entitled to special favors, slapped upon them by their very own despot. But they, too, should prepare for the unexpected.
Denise Beck-Clark
Yonkers, New York
America’s future should not be looked upon in isolation, because imbalance is a worldwide problem. We are all living through a “storm” of our own making and, as events unfold, we should perhaps ask “why?” and “how?”— particularly in relation to the influence of evil and the destruction it has caused. Will reason, logic, and truth, and coming together to face our changing world, not bring about a positive, healthy and balanced future?
Julia Griffin
Laxfield, Suffolk
United Kingdom
Sylvia, part of the portrait series, Women Who Refuse to be Invisible
(a series that focuses on women over 60), mixed media, by Anastasia Andersen
In many societies, from ancient Greece to present-day Asian and Native American cultures, elders are revered for their wisdom and ability to pass down traditional values and traditions, and they remain an integral part of their families and communities. But in America they are shunted aside. The affluent segregate themselves in gated senior communities or on cruises, making only occasional contact with their families. The less fortunate struggle to survive with inadequate governmental support for medical, home care, and transportation needs.
We’re fixated on physical fitness and beauty, spending billions on cosmetic surgery and serums to keep us looking younger than our chronological age. Yes, Biden appears old, even frail, but we should evaluate him by his judgment and wisdom, not his looks.
At 82, I’ve trademarked my business, Creative Crone Press. I’m proud to flaunt my age. Other women can too!
Julie Lomoe
Wynantskill, New York
I have always thought that Joe Biden is the opposite—a “mensch,” a decent man who has been through enough personal tragedies that his humanity shines through again and again. Sure, I wish he were ten years younger. (I wish that I were ten years younger too.) However, I would take a mensch over a bully any day.
Joanne Jagoda
Oakland, California
There is nothing united in a nation when a former president pronounces [that he has won] an election he numerically and legally lost, and his infuriation sparks a vicious attack by thousands on the seat of government, and a massive contingent of the populace continues to believe in him and his lie.
There is nothing united about the Supreme Court’s nullification of 108 years of New York state law restricting who can carry a concealed gun, a law supported by eight out of ten New Yorkers. That same Court nullified a 50-year-old law providing women the right to abortion – a Constitutional right legalized in 1973, supported by 52-57% of women, and I surmise, some percentage of men.
As each of these [Supreme Court] events occurred on different days of [one] week, I felt despair while others celebrated. I sought more, and came upon the term “illiberal democracy.”
…According to [Fareed] Zakaria, illiberal democracies are increasing around the world and are increasingly limiting the freedoms of the people they represent.
I fear for my grandchildren and little great-grandson. And yours.
Norma S. Tucker
Bethesda, Maryland
Starting with listing 25 things to be grateful for at the beginning of the day and ending with 25 at the end, I feel a change within myself. Even when it is a horrific day, I focus on one gratitude gem to hang onto. It’s not a complete change, but it is a start.
Margaret Hutchens
Mason City, Iowa
If you will be driving to the Presidential election this year, please commit to filling your car with three other voters, preferably those who are still undecided. Ask your like-minded friends to do the same. That’s a simple way to increase the odds of re-electing a person of decent character to the most influential position in the world.
We find ourselves at a crossroads. Put in motion by the events of January 6, 2021. In retrospect People were plotting ways to co-opt the US government. In Donald Trump they found the perfect carrier for plagues of hatred and bigotry that defined his presidency. Once elected, lies became truth, hatred, shifting of blame, greed, stupidity became the norm.
I was taken unaware. I worked for Obama’s election and for his re-election. Did the same for Hillary Clinton. Yet, ignorance and bigotry won out over a clearly principled, educated, and superior woman candidate.
Aghast at what our country was becoming under Trump’s presidency, I worked hard to elect Democratic candidates up and down the ballot in Arizona where Republican candidates are attempting to seize control.
We must be involved. I hope and long for a better future for all children and grandchildren. We cannot grow weary or despair. Death and destruction in Gaza, Ukraine and Sudan, reproductive rights ended, migrants treated inhumanely, LGBTQ+, trans rights, controlling what people think, book banning and the numerous other rights being assailed within our own country and around the world. I don’t have the luxury of being tired. I cannot surrender my hope.
Linda F Piotrowski
Green Valley, Arizona
As a Canadian, I thank you, merci, for your insightful comment. I take heart in your logic, stamina and hopefulness. It is painful to see the world going backwards, but I pray Americans will ‘fire’ Donald Trump once and for all in November. You have an intelligent, good man in President Joe Biden. Please hang on to him.