In those days there was no high-tech equipment for such tiny preemies. Even today a child born that early is at great risk. The doctor said, “If she lives for twenty-four hours, then we’ll try to feed her.” He meant to say, tactfully, that she wouldn’t last that long.
I didn’t ask to see her before they took her to the nursery. I had not really been ready for a child. In the late 1960s, young women like me were busy being “liberated,” acting rationally, pursuing careers that had just opened up to us, if only we would devote our energies to them and keep childbearing in its place. I thought I was being strong.
The year before, my friend Cara’s first son had been born with a hole in his heart. Today, the defect would be corrected with routine surgery. Then, it was more complex. Cara didn’t look at him before he was air-lifted to a larger hospital. If he survived, there would be plenty of time for bonding. But he didn’t survive. The day he was buried, Cara asked me to come sit with her at home so she wouldn’t have the memory to deal with.
I, too, was wary of memories. Cara had named her son Justin. I never named my daughter. Sometimes, later, I thought I would, secretly. But it seemed too late.
At the hospital, an aide from housekeeping came into my room to empty the trash. “I saw your baby in the nursery,” she said. “She’s cute.”
The comment was such a shock that I couldn’t speak. The aide must not know, as I did, that my child would not be in that nursery for long.
Even then, I didn’t ask to see her. I did not imagine what it must have been like to be alone in that nursery, struggling for breath, without being held. I had lost a lot of blood and was being given a transfusion. It didn’t occur to me that I might have been wheeled down to the nursery all the same. I was focused on getting through the day, not showing weakness, not falling apart.
My daughter lived twelve hours. The next day, after I was released, a woman and her husband stood next to us on the elevator to the lobby, their infant wrapped in a blue blanket in the woman’s arms. It was the hardest elevator ride of my life, remaining composed until the happy parents walked ahead of us out the door and into the sunshine.
I didn’t learn about my grandmother’s loss until she was in her eighties. She had two daughters and one son, my uncle. I don’t remember how the subject came up of the other boy she had borne, who had died in infancy. “I still think about it,” my grandmother said. “What would it be like if I had another child.”
In time, Cara and I both became mothers of vibrant, healthy children who grew up and had much-loved children of their own. But every year I mark my firstborn’s birthday, though there is no grave to visit and no name to call her by. I still wonder what those twelve hours were like for her, in her incubator, her lungs too immature to breathe. I wonder why I didn’t touch her, whisper words of comfort, shower her few difficult hours with love.
If I had to do it again, I would hold her.
I would give her a name.
3 Comments on “Firstborn”
A very powerful and heart-rending story.
Did the baby’s father get a chance to see her?
I was once that baby—-small, sick, not expected to survive. My mom told the story that she and my dad went to look at me in my incubator. “Talk to her, Mary,” my dad said. I’m always impressed by the ambivalence my parents had–not surprisingly– at the sight of their newborn. They had no warning that their baby would be so ill–with a scary skin disorder. But I hope my mom did talk to me. To this day, I feel such sympathy for the newborn in the incubator, so your story struck me deeply. I was lucky. I did survive.
It must have taken courage to write the story. Thank you for doing it so well.
Thank you for sharing these moments and how torn you were and are still thinking about what might have been, even if only for a few hours. You reminded me that even brief Life is precious and naming and witnessing so powerful as a path to peace.
I delivered a stillborn baby girl on Labor day in Sept. 1970. It was a terrible time and i also didnt get to hold her or see her. I was 24 and she was my 2nd child. i didnt know i could ask for these things!! I was young and in all kinds of pain. It took years to come to terms with my loss and the hole it left in my heart. On her 13th birthday. i planted a miniature weeping cherry tree (a pale pink one) I was feeling a little stronger by then. A little bit….